Falling behind on tax is far more common than people admit. A quiet quarter, a big customer who pays late, a BAS or income tax bill that lands at the wrong moment, and suddenly the ATO is owed money you don't have on hand. If that's you right now, take a breath. An ATO debt is a problem with a process, and the people who come out of it well are almost always the ones who engaged early rather than hoping it would disappear.
Here's how to think about it, and the practical steps that keep a manageable debt from turning into a serious one.
Don't ignore it — this is the one rule that matters
The single worst thing you can do with a tax debt is nothing. The ATO is generally constructive when you reach out before things escalate, and far firmer once a debt has been left to drift. Silence can lead to firmer recovery action, and unpaid business tax debts can in some cases be reported to credit reporting agencies, which may affect your ability to get finance.
Engaging early keeps you in control of the conversation. It signals you're taking the obligation seriously, and it usually opens the door to options that simply aren't on the table once enforcement has begun.
Lodge on time, even if you can't pay
This trips a lot of people up: lodging and paying are two separate obligations. You should always lodge your BAS or tax return by the due date even if you can't pay the amount owing.
Why it matters:
- Failure to lodge can attract its own penalties, on top of the tax you already owe.
- Lodging on time keeps your record clean and makes the ATO far more willing to work with you on the payment side.
- You can't usually set up a payment plan until the ATO knows the actual amount of the debt — and that comes from a lodged return or BAS.
In short: lodge first, then deal with how to pay. Hiding the return to delay the bill only deepens the hole.
Ask about a payment plan
The ATO can often arrange a payment plan that spreads a debt into regular instalments over time, instead of demanding the full amount at once. For many individuals and small businesses, this is the most practical way back to a clean slate.
- Smaller debts can sometimes be set up online through your myGov or ATO online account, or via your registered tax agent — without a phone call.
- Larger or more complex debts usually need a conversation with the ATO, where you propose instalments your cash flow can genuinely sustain.
- Once a plan is in place, the key is to keep up the payments. A defaulted plan is harder to renegotiate than the first one was.
A payment plan doesn't make the debt vanish, and interest generally still applies to the outstanding balance (check the current ATO rate). But it keeps you compliant, shows good faith, and helps you avoid harsher recovery action while you work the balance down.
The GIC change that raises the real cost of carrying debt
There's an important shift you need to factor in. From 1 July 2025, the General Interest Charge (GIC) and the Shortfall Interest Charge (SIC) on tax debts are no longer tax-deductible.
Previously, the interest the ATO charged on an overdue debt could often be claimed as a deduction, which softened its real cost. That deduction is gone. The headline interest rate is what it is — check the current ATO rate — but with no deduction to offset it, the true after-tax cost of carrying an ATO debt is now higher than it used to be.
What this means in practice:
- Sitting on an ATO debt is more expensive in real terms than it was before the change.
- It's worth comparing the cost of an ATO payment plan against other funding — for example, a bank loan or business overdraft — where the interest may be deductible and the rate may be lower.
- The right answer depends on your numbers, but the old assumption that ATO debt is "cheap" debt no longer holds. Run the comparison rather than defaulting to the ATO plan out of habit.
We can help you work through whether a payment plan or alternative finance leaves you better off once tax and deductibility are taken into account.
Stop it happening again
A one-off tax debt is bad luck. A recurring one is usually a cash-flow signal worth addressing at the source. Fixing how you set money aside often matters more than the repayment plan itself.
- Set money aside as you earn — a separate bank account for GST, PAYG and income tax keeps it from being spent before it's due.
- Remember your GST obligations if your turnover is at or above the $75,000 registration threshold, and budget for that 10% as money you're holding for the ATO, not income.
- Keep future lodgements on time to maintain goodwill and avoid penalties stacking up.
- Talk to the ATO or your tax agent before the due date if you can see a problem coming — early warning gives you options.
Where we come in
If you have an ATO debt and want a clear, realistic plan, we can help you lodge what's outstanding, talk to the ATO, structure a payment plan you can actually meet, and weigh it against other funding now that GIC isn't deductible. The aim is a path back to a clean slate without the bill quietly compounding in the background.
Book a chat at nebulaaccounting.au or call 0433 822 227.
This article is general information only and does not take account of your personal circumstances — it is not personal tax, financial or legal advice. Tax laws change and apply differently to different people. Nebula Accounting Pty Ltd is a registered tax agent (No. 26259377); please speak with us or check with the ATO before acting.