Study loans are one of the most misunderstood items in the Australian tax system. People often describe having "paid off HECS this year" when what actually happened was a compulsory repayment triggered by their income. Others are startled by a tax bill despite having had tax withheld from every pay.

The mechanics are not complicated, but they work differently enough from ordinary debt that it is worth understanding them properly.

How repayment actually works

A HELP debt — which covers HECS-HELP, FEE-HELP, VET Student Loans and several others — carries no interest in the conventional sense and has no fixed repayment schedule.

Instead, once your income passes an annual threshold, a compulsory repayment is calculated as part of your tax return. The rate rises in steps as income increases. Both the threshold and the rates are set each year, so the figures that applied when you studied are not the figures that apply now.

The repayment is not optional and it is not a bill you receive separately. It is worked out at assessment and either reduces your refund or increases the amount you owe.

Repayment income is broader than salary

This is the first place people get caught. The figure used is repayment income, not simply your wage.

It includes your taxable income plus several add-backs: reportable fringe benefits, total net investment losses (including a negatively geared property), reportable employer super contributions such as salary sacrifice, and certain exempt foreign employment income.

The consequence surprises people. Salary sacrificing into super reduces your taxable income but is added back for this purpose. Negative gearing on a rental reduces taxable income and is likewise added back. Neither strategy reduces your compulsory study loan repayment, even though both reduce your income tax.

Why your employer's withholding may not be enough

When you start a job you tell your employer about the loan on your tax file number declaration. They then withhold an additional amount from each pay to cover the expected repayment.

That works well with one job. It works poorly in three common situations.

  • You did not tell them. If the declaration did not flag the loan, no extra amount has been withheld all year, and the full repayment lands at assessment.
  • You have more than one job. Each employer withholds based only on what they pay you. Two jobs of $45,000 each might individually sit near or below the threshold, while your combined income sits well above it. Nobody has withheld for the gap.
  • You have income outside employment. Sole trader income, freelance work, investment income or capital gains all feed into repayment income, and no employer is withholding against any of it.

This is the single most common cause of the "I had a HECS debt and got a tax bill" conversation, and it is almost always the side income.

Indexation

The balance is indexed annually on 1 June, which keeps it in line with the cost of living rather than charging interest.

Timing is worth understanding here. Indexation is applied to the balance outstanding at that point, and compulsory repayments from your assessment are credited when the assessment is processed, which is usually later. That sequencing is why a balance can appear to move in ways people do not expect.

Voluntary repayments

You can make voluntary repayments at any time, and they reduce the balance directly.

Whether that is the right use of money is a genuinely personal question. A study loan is generally the cheapest debt most people will ever hold, so paying it down ahead of a mortgage, a car loan or credit card debt is rarely the most efficient choice. On the other hand some people simply want it gone, and there is nothing wrong with that.

What a voluntary repayment does not do is remove the compulsory repayment for a year in which your income exceeded the threshold. That is calculated regardless.

If you are heading overseas

Moving abroad does not suspend the obligation. If you are a non-resident for tax purposes with a study loan, you have reporting obligations on your worldwide income, and repayments can still apply. People who leave without dealing with this often return to a considerably larger problem than the one they left.

Planning around it

If you have a study loan and any income beyond a single salaried job, the sensible move is to estimate the likely repayment during the year rather than discovering it at lodgement. Setting aside a portion of side income as you earn it turns a shock into a non-event.

If you would like us to estimate your compulsory repayment, work out how much to set aside from side income, or review how salary sacrifice and negative gearing interact with your loan, we can help. Book a chat at nebulaaccounting.au or call 0433 822 227.

This article is general information only and does not take account of your personal circumstances — it is not personal tax, financial or legal advice. Tax laws change and apply differently to different people. Nebula Accounting Pty Ltd is a registered tax agent (No. 26259377); please speak with us or check with the ATO before acting.

General Advice Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not constitute financial product advice, tax advice specific to your circumstances, or a recommendation to take any particular action. It has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on any information in this article, you should consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and seek independent professional advice.